Help please what high school do you think I should go to?

I have a year to decide but at my middle school there are two high schools that people go to after this middle school--let's call them Cow High School and Fairy High School. My parents are okay with me going to either one. Cow has lots and lots of people, 3 times as many as at Fairy. It's a bit dumpy in my opinion and they have pretty high drop-out rates. Fairy is a pretty new place right next to my church and their education is slightly better than at Cow. ALL my friends are going to Cow, though. Even people I think I might be friends with in the future are going there. So I'm not really sure where I should go. I thought if I went to Fairy I would have practically a new start which would be nice, but my friends really really want me to go to Fairy. I have no idea!!! If you need more information just say so and I will add it in the question! HELP PLEASE :(